Male consuming fish oil capsule

The Fitties Blog

Supplement Buyers Guide for Men: Tailored by Budget and Goal

October 30, 2023 | Supplements and Nutrition

Every day, millions of men around the world embark on a journey to transform their bodies. Whether it's shedding a few extra pounds, building lean muscle, or both, the path to physical transformation often goes beyond just diet and exercise. This is where supplements come into play—and the reason why we developed this supplement buyers guide for men.

But here's a question that often arises: "Do I really need supplements?" While the simple answer might be 'no', the more nuanced answer is that while they aren't always necessary, supplements can give you a potential advantage in your fitness journey. They can bridge nutritional gaps, enhance performance, speed up recovery, or even just make the process smoother.

However, with the plethora of options available in the market, things can get overwhelming quickly. Do you opt for that popular fat burner or invest in a high-quality protein powder? And how do you factor in the budget constraints? Every brand promises results, but which ones are really worth your money and align with your goals?

Before we dive into the nitty-gritty, there's an important thing to remember. Our bodies are wonderfully unique, and what offers tremendous results for one person might be mediocre for another. This individual variability means that while this guide aims to be comprehensive, you should always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new supplement regimen.

This guide seeks to simplify this dilemma. By the end, you'll have a clearer idea about which supplements align best with your goals, all tiered based on how much you're willing or able to spend. Whether you're a college student on a tight budget or someone ready to invest top dollar in premium products, we've got recommendations for you.

Let's start by understanding the foundational role of diet and exercise, and where supplements fit into this equation.

Understanding the Basics

The realm of fitness, at its core, revolves around the interplay of diet, exercise, and recovery. These elements form the trinity upon which every successful fitness journey is built. However, the allure of quick results often puts supplements in the limelight, sometimes overshadowing the basics. Let's take a step back and truly grasp the foundational aspects.

The Role of Diet and Exercise

Diet: It's often said that "abs are made in the kitchen," and there's a lot of truth to that. Your dietary choices have a profound impact on your body's composition. Whether you're trying to lose weight, gain muscle, or maintain your current physique, what you consume plays a pivotal role.

Exercise: While diet can determine your body's composition, exercise dictates its shape and functionality. Depending on your goals, the type, intensity, and duration of your workouts will vary.

  • Cardiovascular Training: Great for heart health, endurance, and burning calories.
  • Strength Training: Essential for building muscle mass, enhancing bone density, and boosting metabolism.

Supplements: A Complement, Not a Replacement

The word "supplement" itself suggests an addition or enhancement rather than a foundation. While they can offer benefits, it's essential to recognize that they cannot replace a balanced diet or regular exercise.

  • Filling Nutritional Gaps: Even with a well-planned diet, there might be certain nutrients you're not getting enough of. Supplements can help bridge these gaps.
  • Enhancing Performance: Some supplements can enhance workout performance, allowing you to train harder or recover faster, giving an edge in your fitness journey.

Essential vs. Non-essential Supplements

Understanding the difference between essential and non-essential supplements can save both your money and effort:

  • Essential Supplements: These are the ones that can benefit almost everyone, irrespective of their fitness goals. For instance, a multivitamin might be essential if your diet lacks a variety of fruits and vegetables. Similarly, Omega-3 supplements can be beneficial if you don't consume fatty fish regularly.
  • Non-essential Supplements: These are goal-specific. For example, a weight gainer might be non-essential for someone trying to lose weight but could be beneficial for someone struggling to gain weight. Similarly, a pre-workout supplement is non-essential but can boost energy levels for workouts.

It's always important to remember that supplements should be chosen based on individual needs and goals. With this foundation set, we can now delve into how to select the right supplements tailored to your objectives and budget.

Budget Tiers

Navigating the supplement industry can feel like walking through a maze. With countless brands, ingredients, and price points, it's easy to get lost in the plethora of options. This is why budgeting becomes crucial. Not only does it help you stay within your financial limits, but it also ensures that you're getting the most bang for your buck.

Understanding budget tiers can help you make informed decisions about which supplements to prioritize based on your financial situation. Let's break down the tiers:

Budget Tier 1: Basic (For those on a tight budget)

This tier is for those who are just starting their fitness journey or those who are on a strict budget. Maybe you're a student, or you're saving for something big. Either way, you need supplements that provide the maximum impact for a minimal price.

Key Characteristics:

  • Cost-Effective: These supplements offer essential benefits without burning a hole in your pocket. They are the basics that can make a noticeable difference in your journey.
  • Widely Available: Typically, these supplements are easy to find, whether it's online or at your local health store.
  • Minimal Frills: At this tier, you're paying primarily for the active ingredient without the added bells and whistles. Branding, packaging, and extra ingredients are often simplified to keep costs down.

Budget Tier 2: Intermediate (For those with a moderate budget)

You've got a bit more to spend and are looking for something that offers a little extra. This tier balances cost with quality, providing products that offer additional benefits, better purity, or enhanced formulations.

Key Characteristics:

  • Better Formulations: These supplements might offer faster absorption, longer-lasting effects, or a combination of beneficial ingredients.
  • Reputable Brands: While still affordable, brands in this tier often invest more in research, quality assurance, and customer education.
  • Added Benefits: Beyond the primary ingredient, you might find added vitamins, minerals, or other beneficial compounds that synergize well.

Budget Tier 3: Premium (For those willing to invest more for top-notch products)

If you're willing to invest in the best of the best, this tier is for you. Whether you're an athlete, a bodybuilder, or simply someone who wants premium products, these supplements offer the pinnacle of what the industry has to offer.

Key Characteristics:

  • Top Quality Ingredients: The purity and potency of ingredients in this tier are often unparalleled.
  • Cutting-edge Research: These products often leverage the latest scientific research and might even contain patented or trademarked ingredients.
  • Brand Trustworthiness: Brands, like Fitties, that are in this tier often have a strong reputation, with rigorous third-party testing, transparent sourcing, and excellent customer support.

While these tiers give a general idea, it's essential to remember that the most expensive supplement isn't always the best for your needs. Always assess your goals, do thorough research, and consult with healthcare professionals to ensure you're making the right choices for your unique situation.

Fat Loss Goal

Ah, the elusive quest for fat loss. For many, shedding those extra pounds can seem like an uphill battle. Diet and exercise remain the undisputed champions in this arena, but the right supplements can potentially aid the process, giving you a bit of an edge.

When you're targeting fat loss, the primary objective is to create a caloric deficit. This means burning more calories than you're consuming. Supplements can play a role in various ways: by boosting metabolism, reducing appetite, or even aiding in fat oxidation. Let's explore these, tier by tier.

Budget Tier 1: Basic

Green Tea Extract

Green tea has been consumed for centuries and has a myriad of health benefits, one of which is aiding in fat loss. The magic lies in its catechins, particularly EGCG (Epigallocatechin gallate). These compounds can boost metabolism, aiding the body's ability to burn fat. Moreover, the mild caffeine content in green tea can provide a gentle energy lift, making it easier to get through workouts or just your day in general.

Recommended Dose: 250-500 mg daily.


Caffeine is a staple in most fat burners for a good reason. It not only energizes your body but also boosts your metabolism, helping you burn more calories. Moreover, caffeine can increase adrenaline levels, which can, in turn, aid in breaking down body fat. And the good news? You don't need fancy pills. A simple cup of black coffee could give you a dose of caffeine. However, for those who prefer pills or aren't coffee enthusiasts, caffeine capsules are an affordable option.

Recommended Dose: 100-200 mg, taken 30 minutes before a workout or as needed (Note: Don't overdo it; excessive caffeine can lead to jitters, insomnia, or other side effects.).

Budget Tier 2: Intermediate

CLA (Conjugated Linoleic Acid)

Derived primarily from safflower oil, CLA has gained popularity as a fat loss supplement. While human studies offer mixed results, some suggest that CLA can help reduce body fat, particularly in the abdominal area. It's believed to work by modulating fat metabolism, essentially aiding in the breakdown and reduction of fat storage.

Recommended Dose: 3,000-6,000 mg daily, taken with meals.


This amino acid plays a critical role in transporting fatty acids into the mitochondria of cells, where they're burned for energy. Thus, L-Carnitine can potentially enhance fat oxidation. While our bodies naturally produce L-Carnitine, and it's present in foods like red meat, taking a supplement might benefit those on a reduced-calorie diet or vegetarians and vegans.

Recommended Dose: 1,000-2,000 mg daily, taken on an empty stomach.

Budget Tier 3: Premium

Thermogenic Fat Burners

Thermogenics are designed to raise your body temperature, theoretically increasing your calorie expenditure. They often contain a combination of ingredients like caffeine, green tea extract, capsaicin, and more. These supplements come at a premium because they offer a multi-faceted approach, combining various fat-burning ingredients in one pill.

Recommended Dose: Varies by product. Always follow the manufacturer's recommendations and start with a lower dose to assess tolerance.

Appetite Suppressants

One of the hardest parts of fat loss is dealing with the hunger pangs that come with a caloric deficit. Appetite suppressants, as the name suggests, help reduce appetite, making it easier to stick to your diet. Ingredients like glucomannan, derived from the konjac plant, can create a feeling of fullness, allowing you to comfortably eat less without feeling deprived. Fitties FitFight is another exceptional alternative that works wonders to fight cravings.

Recommended Dose: For glucomannan, 1,000-1,500 mg daily, taken with a glass of water, 30 minutes before meals.

Remember that no supplement can replace the foundational importance of a balanced diet and regular exercise. Supplements can assist, but the real work is done in the kitchen and the gym. Always be wary of products that promise miraculous results without the effort; more often than not, if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.

Muscle Gain Goal

Building muscle is an art and a science. It's about pushing your body to its limits in the gym and then nourishing it with the right nutrients to grow bigger and stronger. While protein-rich foods, consistent workouts, and adequate rest form the core of any muscle-building regimen, supplements can amplify these effects, ensuring you're getting the most out of every rep and set.

The aim with muscle gain supplements isn't merely about increasing size, but also about enhancing performance, reducing muscle breakdown, and speeding up recovery. Here's how you can support your muscle-building ambitions across different budget tiers:

Budget Tier 1: Basic

Whey Protein

The popularity of whey protein isn't unwarranted. It's one of the most efficient and cost-effective ways to ensure you're getting enough protein to support muscle growth. Whey protein is quickly digested, making it an excellent choice post-workout when your muscles are craving nutrients. Rich in essential amino acids, especially leucine, whey protein stimulates muscle protein synthesis, the process responsible for muscle growth. If you're able to invest in quality whey protein, Fitties FitWhey+ is what you should absolutely consider.

Recommended Dose: 20-50 grams post-workout or as needed to meet daily protein requirements.

Creatine Monohydrate

Creatine is one of the most researched and validated supplements in the fitness world. Stored as creatine phosphate in the muscles, it acts as a quick energy reservoir during high-intensity activities like weightlifting. Supplementing with creatine increases the body's creatine phosphate stores, allowing for improved workout performance, which can lead to greater muscle gains over time. If you're looking for an all-in-one pre-workout/creatine supplement, we recommend Fitties FitBoost+ because of its patented ingredients and exceptionally high quality overall.

Recommended Dose: 5 grams daily; can be taken pre or post-workout. Some prefer a "loading phase" of 20 grams daily for 5-7 days, followed by 5 grams daily thereafter.

Budget Tier 2: Intermediate

BCAAs (Branched Chain Amino Acids)

BCAAs, namely leucine, isoleucine, and valine, play a unique role in muscle growth and recovery. Leucine, in particular, is a potent activator of muscle protein synthesis. While BCAAs are found in any protein source, taking them in isolated form can provide a quick and digestible dose, especially during workouts or in between meals.

Recommended Dose: 5-10 grams before, during, or after workouts.


If you've ever felt a tingly sensation after taking a pre-workout supplement, you've likely experienced the effects of beta-alanine. This amino acid helps produce carnosine, which buffers the lactic acid in muscles during high-intensity exercise. This buffering capability can help delay fatigue, allowing for longer and harder workouts, which can translate to more significant muscle gains over time.

Recommended Dose: 2-5 grams daily, taken before workouts.

Budget Tier 3: Premium

Casein Protein

While whey protein is quickly absorbed, casein takes its time. This slow digestion makes casein an excellent protein source before bed or during prolonged periods without food. It provides a steady release of amino acids, reducing the chances of muscle breakdown during periods of fasting, like sleep.

Recommended Dose: 20-30 grams before bedtime or as a meal replacement.

HMB (Hydroxymethylbutyrate)

HMB, a metabolite of the essential amino acid leucine, has shown promise in reducing muscle protein breakdown and increasing muscle protein synthesis. For those engaging in intensive training, HMB can potentially speed up recovery and reduce muscle soreness, allowing for more frequent and effective training sessions. For HMB, we highly recommend FitRestore because of its patented, medical-grade ingredients and expert formulation.

Recommended Dose: 1-3 grams daily, split into multiple doses and ideally taken with meals. 

Building muscle is a journey that requires patience, dedication, and a commitment to training and nutrition. Supplements, while beneficial, are just one piece of the puzzle. Focus on your overall diet, training regimen, sleep, and stress management. With all these elements in place, and with the aid of the right supplements for your budget, you'll be on the path to achieving your muscle-building goals.

Fat Loss + Muscle Gain Goal (Body Recomposition)

Body recomposition—simultaneously losing fat and gaining muscle—is often hailed as the "holy grail" of fitness. It's a challenging endeavor, as these two goals can sometimes seem at odds with one another. While muscle gain typically requires a caloric surplus, fat loss necessitates a caloric deficit. But with a meticulously planned diet, consistent training, and the right supplements, achieving this feat is within reach.

Let's delve into the supplements that can best support this ambitious pursuit across our budget tiers:

Budget Tier 1: Basic

Whey Protein

Yes, whey protein makes the list again, and here's why: during body recomposition, ensuring adequate protein intake is paramount. Protein supports muscle growth, but it also has a higher thermic effect, meaning your body expends more energy digesting it. This can aid in fat loss. Additionally, protein's satiating effect can help manage hunger during periods of caloric restriction. Again, we recommend Fitties FitWhey+ as the ideal whey protein supplement because of its medical-grade ingredients and industry's highest quality form of whey.

Recommended Dose: 20-30 grams post-workout or as needed to meet daily protein requirements.


The dual role of caffeine becomes even more vital during body recomposition. Its ability to boost metabolism can aid in fat loss, while its performance-enhancing effects can ensure you're still able to push hard in the gym, preserving (or even building) muscle mass even in a calorie-restricted state.

Recommended Dose: 100-200 mg, taken 30 minutes before a workout or as needed (Remember to monitor total daily caffeine intake from all sources.).

Budget Tier 2: Intermediate


When you're striving to lose fat while gaining muscle, muscle preservation is crucial. BCAAs, especially when consumed around workout times, can help prevent muscle protein breakdown, ensuring that the muscles you've worked hard to build aren't being used for energy during calorie-restricted phases.

Recommended Dose: 5-10 grams before, during, or after workouts.


L-Glutamine is the most abundant amino acid in the body and plays a pivotal role in muscle recovery. When your body is under stress, such as during intensive workouts coupled with caloric restriction, supplementing with L-Glutamine can help in muscle recovery and potentially ward off muscle catabolism.

Recommended Dose: 5-10 grams daily, ideally post-workout or before bed.

Budget Tier 3: Premium

EAA (Essential Amino Acids) Supplements

While BCAAs get a lot of the spotlight, there are nine essential amino acids, all of which are vital for muscle protein synthesis. EAA supplements provide all these amino acids in a digestible form, ensuring that muscle-building processes are maximally activated, especially during times when dietary intake might not be optimal.

Recommended Dose: 5-10 grams around workout times or as directed by the product.

Natural Testosterone Boosters

Testosterone is a key player in muscle building and fat loss. Natural testosterone boosters, like fenugreek extract or ashwagandha, can potentially help elevate the body's natural testosterone levels, supporting both muscle gain and fat loss. However, it's crucial to note that these supplements might not be as potent as prescription medications, but they can offer a slight edge, especially in those with lower-than-average testosterone levels.

Recommended Dose: Varies depending on the specific supplement and its active ingredients. Always follow manufacturer recommendations.

Undertaking body recomposition is an advanced fitness goal and demands a synergy of diet, training, rest, and supplementation. The journey might be challenging, but with determination, and by leveraging the right tools and supplements for your budget, the results—seeing a leaner yet more muscular reflection in the mirror—can be incredibly rewarding. Remember, consistency is key, and every step, no matter how small, brings you closer to your goal.

General Tips for Supplement Shopping

Navigating the vast world of supplements can be overwhelming. With an array of products on the shelves and countless brands vying for attention, it's easy to feel lost. But fear not. Armed with a bit of knowledge and discernment, you can make informed decisions that align with your fitness goals and budget.

First and foremost, it's imperative to understand that not all supplements are created equal. When selecting a supplement, always start by scrutinizing the ingredient list. You want to be certain that what's on the label is what's inside the bottle. Look for clear labeling with specific amounts of each ingredient.

This transparency can be a good indicator of a company's integrity. Proprietary blends, where specific ingredient amounts are hidden behind a 'blend' with only the total weight disclosed, can be tricky. While some argue it's to protect their special formula, it also means you, as a consumer, don't know exactly how much of each ingredient you're getting. This can be particularly concerning if you're trying to monitor your intake of certain components.

Another critical aspect of shopping smartly is checking for third-party testing. Reputable brands often send their products to independent labs to verify that they contain the ingredients listed on the label and don't contain any undisclosed substances. This not only ensures you're getting what you paid for but also that the product is free from contaminants.

When considering a new supplement, especially if it's a brand you're unfamiliar with, do a quick online search. Customer reviews, third-party testing results, and any awards or certifications the product might have received can provide insight into its quality and efficacy.

Lastly, always keep in mind your unique needs and sensitivities. Just because a supplement is popular or comes highly recommended doesn't mean it's right for everyone. Some people might have allergies or intolerances to certain ingredients. Always start with a small dose to see how your body reacts, and consult a healthcare professional, especially if you have underlying health conditions or are taking other medications.

In conclusion, the world of supplements is vast and varied, but with a discerning eye and an informed approach, you can find products that align with your goals, enhance your performance, and support your overall well-being. Remember, supplements are just that—a supplement to a balanced diet and a healthy lifestyle. Always prioritize whole foods and good nutrition, and use supplements to fill in the gaps and give you that extra edge in your fitness journey.

Expand your health and fitness knowledge

Uncover a world of knowledge with Fitties' curated blogs, each offering targeted advice and inspiration to elevate your health, fitness, and lifestyle.

  • Closeup of female scooping FitWhey+

    Supplements and Nutrition

    Navigate the nutritional landscape with expert insights and practical advice on supplements and diets for optimal health and peak performance.

    Explore Guides
  • Fitties Brand Ambassador couple

    Fitness and Training

    Revolutionize your fitness game with unique strategies and inspiration to help you achieve your personal best, no matter where you start.

    Explore Guides
  • Senior male mixing salad in kitchen

    Lifestyle and Wellness

    Tap into practical tips, tricks, and wellness fundamentals for a more balanced and health-focused lifestyle.

    Explore Guides